All-Star Batman and Robin #1-2
Written by Linkara Tuesday, 10 November 2009 00:17
|
Doug's Official Facebook Page | Purchase Premium Membership Now! Only available till the end of April! |
-
11.10.2009 - 10:29 | Cowboy
-
03.12.2010 - 21:50 | badgersprite
-
10.14.2010 - 21:03 | DonnyKD
-
07.02.2011 - 00:08 | Johnny User
-
11.10.2009 - 18:33 | jcogginsaam i the only one who is having the video stop right after vale gets buzzed?
-
03.06.2013 - 19:11 | AnimeDCMarvelFanThe spirit directed by our good friend Miller himself.
-
He's sort of like Jeff Goldbloom, to be taken in small doses. I like his reviews and yeah Frank tends to hyper sexualize his female protagonists and...well...actually everyone that's got a vagina is pretty much free game to Frank, but at least he gives his female characters personality. They may be sexual, sometimes excessively, but they're still characters. They have back stories, sometimes ridiculously elaborate psyches and oftentimes get the best lines in his work. Electra was absolutely enthralling in 'Man with no fear' and the queen in '300' is for the most part tenacious and extravagantly earnest, both as a ruler, a wife and a mother.
I mean, I'm an artist. I draw manga style art__well it's actually more like whatever I want. It's mostly inspired by 'Bleach', 'Hellsing' and Monkey Punch but with Don Bluth and Jamie Hewlett motifs for personal preference__but I'm just saying: I make sexy women, who say sexual things, and I don't care. There's nothing wrong with being flirtatious or even just plainly explicit: it all depends on context.
I get what Linkara's griping about, but he seems altogether irritated by anything sensuous occuring in the rhetoric period. It's a pulpy noir, it's going to have femme fatales. And also a lot of women don't consider dressing attractively as a halmark of intellectual regression or a sentimentally vacuous personality. Why is it when a woman agrandizes her body it's "bad"? Is this just a christian thing or an American thing? Because in Japan they learned that you can have an woman be a sentimentally literate character and have a sexually comedic component to her.
I'm not saying a female character has to have a sexual component to be palatable I'm just saying it's really being over ridiculed.
-
09.23.2012 - 01:02 | Sewblon
-
01.19.2013 - 22:48 | pomaflahHe said that explicitly, actually. He objects to their sexiness having no purpose except the enjoyment of the male reader.
-
11.10.2009 - 00:35 | Joker Jr.
-
11.10.2009 - 00:35 | Coldguy
-
11.10.2009 - 00:37 | BatOtaku13
-
11.10.2009 - 00:45 | pharmmajor
-
11.11.2009 - 11:57 | pharmmajor
-
I'll be waiting so long for this. Go Linkara!
But seriously, I'll have to wait a little more. I haven't watched the video because it's still loading. So thumbs down for commenting without seeing the video, please.
-
11.10.2009 - 02:49 | LunarLycan
-
11.10.2009 - 00:56 | Transformers03Awesome, I'am one of the first comments.
-
11.10.2009 - 00:59 | smurph
-
[quote=smurph]
Just think, it could have been worse. How you ask? We could have had to endure the pain of overused ellipses between every one of the narrator's fragmented thoughts.[/quote]
Oh good lord... (ellipses) I can't imagine how horrible it would have been... (ellipses) if Miller had resorted to that.
-
11.10.2009 - 01:19 | iamnotincompliance
-
03.14.2010 - 00:48 | CrazyChris576
-
11.10.2009 - 01:18 | SnapperCarr
-
11.10.2009 - 01:18 | kayla
-
11.10.2009 - 01:25 | LunarLycan
-
11.10.2009 - 01:28 | LauraRiddle
Gotta love how even though Vicky Vale is beaten to a pulp, her makeup is [i]perfect[/i]. Also, I have no problem w/female heroines being a size 0 and wearing less-than-practical outfits, it's when, as you've said, that they're just drawn for eye-candy that it's becoming ridiculous.
I remember skimming through this at the bookstore and thought about buying it because of the art, and then I noticed the ass-shot. Nothing good can come from an ass-shot.
Good vid, keep 'em coming!
-
11.11.2009 - 17:05 | mumbls
-
[quote=mumbls]So, what are your thoughts on Powergirl? ;) [/quote]
Hey, Power Girl at least has a personality to go with her 'Super Boobs'.
Virtually EVERY SINGLE ONE of Frank Miller's women are sexed-up whores.
I mean hell, just look at what he does to Black Canary, Catwoman and Wonder Woman when they come along.
And of course, the Vicki Vale strippathon doesn't stop at the first issue.
-
11.10.2009 - 01:31 | TamLinAlong with last year's Miller-directed "The Spirit", I hold up this comic as final, definitive proof that the man has totally and completely lost his fucking mind.
-
11.10.2009 - 01:36 | ArkireHaha,
Another great vid... Keep it up :lol:
-
11.10.2009 - 01:40 | MPSai
-
11.11.2009 - 12:19 | GenyosaiDude... That's genius.
-
Frank had no control over the Robocop movies. They are entirely different from his original screenplay. I highly recommend you read the comic adaptation of his Robocop 2 script. Great stuff!
-
11.10.2009 - 01:43 | Disposable_Hero
-
Yeah, Frank Miller has probably lost it, basically when reading All Star Batman & Robin I had to convince myself that it was a Elseworlds tale and then I was able to enjoy it more, because as you stated repeatedly in your review, this IS NOT the real Batman!
Additionally I have to ask, you really didn't like the movie adaptations of "Sin City" or "300"? I really dig those two movies but I will agree "The Spirit" is...umm...something else....great review as always
:evil:
-
11.10.2009 - 01:57 | Linkara
-
11.11.2009 - 16:06 | LuisDArcadiaWhy is 300 stupid?
It is kinda stupid in the way it uses the concept of 'freedom'. Movie goers nowadays do not have the same concept of freedom Spartans had on those days. I think that's the reason for some people to interpret the movie as an allegory of the war on terror and all...
But I think it captures perfectly the crude Spartan ideals of strenth and of giving one's life to the Polis.
Loved the way they used the legendary laconic phrases were transformed into action movie's one-liners...
(And the fighting scenes were great :P )
Is it only the movie adaptation you are talking about? Is it the way it was adapted?
(sorry about my english, it is not my native language)
-
11.10.2009 - 01:49 | ComicBookGamerI hated this series. Im glad you finally made a video for it. but, I fucking love Frnak Miller! He's the reason why I got into comics. Sin CIty is amazing and I love most of his other work with Batman and Daredevil. Thats why this comic dissapointed me so much, take my favorite super hero and one of my favorite wrtiters (and Jim Lee) and you get... shit. go figure.
-
11.10.2009 - 01:55 | soldierstar
-
11.10.2009 - 01:59 | ThatKidInTheWheelchairYou know what the sad thing about this is? I can honestly see how this could have been a good story. Even scarier, I can even picture Batman actually just kinda taking DRAT(Dick gRayson Age Twelve) without explaining anything about it. However, only someone as evil as Crazy Steve would flat out kidnap a twelve year old kid, force him to become his ward and sidekick(without even telling him he'd done so), and then swear at him more often than an "emo" kid trying to act tough around his friends.
-
01.19.2013 - 22:53 | pomaflahYou have to think of Dick as Bruce's adopted son and Robin as Batman's squire. The Dark Knight wouldn't kidnap his squire, because it would be counterproductive and stupid. Bruce loves Dick and is raising him as a sort of mentor/older brother and training him to be Robin as Batman.
-
11.10.2009 - 02:00 | DaBabyGorilla
-
11.10.2009 - 02:05 | snakestealth24
-
11.10.2009 - 02:07 | LikaLaruku
ASBM: You'll come (& possibly leave) for the Frank Miller & Stay for the Stan Lee.
All Star Batman & Robin: To Boldly Go where No Logic has Gone Before.
Let's play a drinking game. Every time a character repeats anything they say,repeats anything they say, you have to take a shot (take a shot). Paramedics will be standing by.
Lol, this has more unintentional gay/pedo jokes than I remembered. If I hadn't read this before, I'd expect it to end in rape. Wait...Joker came off as really gay in DKR (yay!) & Gordon made an unintentional pedo joke in it too. Does Miller do this in everything he writes?
-
11.10.2009 - 03:10 | tiggerpetesorry, but it is Jim Lee (one of the founders of Image, and the founder of Wildstorm comics) not Stan Lee (Marvel creator extraordinaire) just had to point that out.