Hana-Kimi
Written by Y Ruler of Time Saturday, 28 March 2009 23:35
Possible Spoilers
|
Doug's Official Facebook Page | Order the 4th Year Anniversary autographed image! Less Than 100 Left! Once they're gone they're gone! |
-
03.28.2009 - 20:56 | ReignfireThe FLCL anime is great but the manga came after it and changed the atmosphere a bit.. I don't really want to see a FLCL review. I'd rather see something more harem-ish like Love Hina.
-
03.28.2009 - 20:14 | Arc_v2.0
-
03.28.2009 - 20:19 | Lotus Prince
I definitely enjoyed this review, and I'm happy to see that you speak louder and more clearly. And you even toned down the swearing! Again, I think that swearing can accent thoughts very appropriately, but that too much just makes the whole thing redundant. Also, I'm glad to see that you've added your personal touch, regarding quirky clips and your section titles, like the Japanese knowledge portion.
Not that your Naruto review was poor (I actually liked it a lot), but congratulations on a definite improvement!
-
03.28.2009 - 20:41 | Testtube173Alright enough for the appetizers lets get to something beefy. You've established your style and are a total joy to watch. So lets have you tackle a big dog!
-
I'm a huge manga fan and I'm glad that someone on the site is finally reviewing it exclusively. I've only read the first few chapters of this series and it didn't appeal to me so I skipped it. I was worried that you'd stick with mainstream series like Naruto, Bleach, and Dragonball but I'm glad that you reviewed something more obscure. I can't wait to see more.
-
03.28.2009 - 20:52 | ChaosD1
-
03.28.2009 - 20:55 | CluckersHaha, that was a very great review. I am actually a fan of the Dorama based on this manga. Now that I've heard more about the manga, I'm glad that the Dorama doesn't keep too close to the manga... well, of course it's even more obvious there that Mizuki is a girl haha
But anyway thanks for the good laugh! Especially the "Boy's School = Prison?"comment... I actually had to stop the video because I was laughing so hard I couldn't follow anymore... that's always a good thing :D
-
03.28.2009 - 21:00 | MatsuJun
-
Just wanted to point out the hana kimi has been in print since the 90's and she's the man came out around 2004
Finished watching: Although I do agree with you on a lot of points this was one of the first manga series I completed, so I have a lot of nostalgic feeling towards it. I don't know if I would like it as much anymore though. Also for those interested in gender benders I would suggest looking into HOUROU MUSUKO. It is the story of a grade school boy realizing that he wants to be a girl.
-
03.28.2009 - 22:06 | KanasheReally nice review. Also the personal touch was a nice addition, alon' with the information moments. Gotta say this manga for some reason mostly reminds me of thoes teen soap operas, only the major difference is that you can laugh at thoes. While this one giant snooze fest of prediction.
-
03.28.2009 - 22:14 | Moondoggie
-
03.28.2009 - 22:19 | Divock - That was actually...still suprisingly entertaining.
You really improved from your last video, and when you get the chance, you should get your own video camera (when you get the chance being the key words).
Can't wait to see what else you're doing, also, I am interested in the "forbidden" list.
-
Really nice review.
Good work with the camera and the "two weeks ago" part was just great.
To the manga, I can`t say much.
Personally I am a man but I have to admit I read at last Ouran High school Host Club which in my opinion has a few great moments, but often a "terrible" artwork, while they manage it to make fun about some Shojou clichees, while also making them part of their own storys.
Well...
okay, a few suggestions for the future perhaps:
Pokemon Adventures, at last the chapters of the Kanto arc. Surprisingly, this manga was less harmless then the anime, as that for example Pokemon and humans die and Ash is almost killed in some instances. Also Team rocket, not represented by this three idiots which I still like, is more dangerous by having different gym leaders on their payroll.
Chrno Crusade:
A Shonen Manga, created by a male mangaka, but with a 16 year old nun as the main heroin. Combined with a good mixture of "action", humor and romantic, as Rosette Christopher and her friend Chrno, a devil/demon, are trying to find the kidnapped brother of the girl, while also stopping a demon called Aeon to destroy the world in one of this old "I will rebuild the world by first destroying it" plots.
Artwork is sometimes different, but at the whole it looks like something you would draw on an animation cell.
The anime to it... Gonzo Studios. Don`t even watch it. It is terrible!
Shaman King
Difficult perhaps, as that the manga is still going on because the mangaka is a lazy asshole.
But I think god if you want to make fun of it in such a way as how many charakters are always introduced in it, which are killed of only a few chapters later.
... wait, that`s the same concept of Bleach!
-
03.28.2009 - 22:52 | jakerose20And another great review , i really enjoyed watching this even though i didnt know the manga.
That you had some focus on yourself and not only the manga was nicely done and you didn't overdo it.
-
03.28.2009 - 23:06 | lenkagreat review, I also liked the Naruto one a lot (the series is FINALLY getting good again)
I actually never heard of Hana Kimi and it seems like I didnt miss much:P
Anyways - what I wanted to say is - I am happy to see you on this site, I am happy to watch your reviews and I will be looking forward to watching the next one:)
-
03.29.2009 - 00:47 | Rahhel
-
03.29.2009 - 01:52 | rmlohner
-
03.29.2009 - 02:17 | MKH90Sweet review. Seems like a series I'll skip because it apparently completely obliterates the concept known as "common sense" :P
As for ideas for upcoming reviews;
Bokurano - Mecha anime/manga with darker twists than in Neon Genesis Evangelion. What can go wrong with such a fine idea?
Narutaru (translated to Shadow Star in the States) - Take Digimon and add psychological cruelty. Sweetness. Also has both manga and anime versions.
Yes, I have a theme going on here, does it show?
-
03.29.2009 - 02:21 | DrGero
Aww, before I noticed the title, I thought you were going to review CUTExGUY, judging by the thumbnail. (CxG is a manga by Makoto Tateno I read a few chapters of. Can't really remember if they were good.)
Still, I enjoyed this video. I vaguely remember hearing of it, but didn't know any details.
I didn't the video particularly funny myself, but I was kept interested enough to watch the entire thing, and maybe that's what the goal was. I really like these sort-of reviews.
One thing I'll mention (although most probably have already), is the editing. Whenever the scene changes from manga, to live action, then back to manga, you can see a flash of the previous manga scene. It's very distracting, but I caught that 'Intro' video, so it didn't bother me too much.
Keep up the good work.
-
03.29.2009 - 02:36 | sanjithecook
-
03.29.2009 - 03:31 | lolo:confused:
i actually liked hana kimi. however, i'll be the first to admit that it is total shojo. there is almost nothing in the story to appeal to a straight male, and when you get down to it, the story line isn't that fast paced or deep. i guess i'm just a sucker for bishonen.
i really liked the t v adaptions. :whistle:
-
03.29.2009 - 04:09 | mr99cm
-
03.29.2009 - 05:08 | Chechi25
-
03.29.2009 - 05:10 | Phelous
Haha awesome review. What a silly story, I can't stand characters like that. Oh I'll just rearrange my whole life because of this person I don't even know yet. I think it would have been better if Sano didn't know she was a girl. So it ends with Sano not liking her anymore when he finds out and Mizuki realizes she wasted all this time on a gay guy. That would have been some nice irony.
Loved at the end "creepier than usual".
-
03.29.2009 - 05:22 | Aburame135Haha! that was great, much funnier than your last one, keep it up!
-
03.29.2009 - 06:26 | The Random Guy