nicee
written by regt123 , August 03, 2008

anime is so awesome

...
written by ThatDudeInTheSuede , August 03, 2008

d'oh! can't even get that right! man you guys are fast!

...
written by regt123 , August 03, 2008

haha i just got lucky
and wow, that pocky is good

...
written by TylerDirty529 , August 03, 2008

The Donald Trump joke was hilarious, the way you said the line was perfect!

Where is the funny?
written by aa_bb_cc , August 03, 2008

I’m sorry to say this, but this episode was pretty boring.
I enjoyed your last episode (since you made fun of crappy AMVs).
But this episode had no comedic value whatsoever.
Instead of focusing just on AMVs, why don’t you review bad anime shows or movies?

...
written by Alterii , August 03, 2008

It might be amusing if you compare a really bad one to an awesome one.

Anyway, I didn't know people actually made good AMVs. O: I'm not too into them myself, but my friend's always watching them on youtube. I'll have to tell her about your reviews.

I'm sure it took a lot of work…
written by TheNumberOneShmuck , August 03, 2008

But the AMV just wasn't that good IMO :

I firmly believe that one I recommended in your last video was better. In fact, I think I'm gonna post that link again, just to make sure you watch it

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHZqxecCukg

Watch it, NAO, mortal! The Shmuck commands it!

...
written by Gene , August 03, 2008

Although the AMV you linked kicks complete ass and then some, I found the episode short with little comedic value. Overall good, but try and make your screen time a little longer

...
written by Shinigami , August 03, 2008

I salute you! You are defenetly talented and you make thease videos from subject that is also close to me. Nothing bad to say.

I'm not a big fan of Anime Music Videos
written by storage and disposal , August 03, 2008

I thought your first AMV video was pretty funny. I admire the work this guy put into it, but it isn't really equal great art to me. Personally, if someone really did spend years making an AMV, I would of it as a complete waste of time.

...
written by Mr Fist , August 03, 2008

That was great. Could we make requests for AMVs you can recommend (if you feel they're worth it)?

If so, I'd like to request you to review anything by Tyler_yj. Most notably 'Jihaku' which is absolutely terrific and it contains 117 anime! Other notable mentions is 'Beautiful Lie' (Paranoia Agent) & 'Tsumibito No Kashou' (Full Metal Alchemist).

Much obliged, I hope.

...
written by Zooniverse , August 03, 2008

I like Anime Heaven. But would like to see Anime Hell as well. ^_^

Rubbed people the wrong way....
written by Bennett the Sage , August 03, 2008

....didn't know there way anyone else that was put off by that than me.

...
written by Sl0th , August 03, 2008

Its a real sign of my misspent youth that I recognized the majority of the anime featured in that video with just a glance. Including several that I didn't watch more than an episode or two in its series.

...
written by Oldemar , August 03, 2008

SIXTYNINE?!!!1111

That would be my interpretation of "in abundance"

Comedic Value
written by SuperDrops , August 03, 2008

Normally I only lurk and don't comment, but here I felt that a comment was in order.

Now some people have complained about the lack of comedic value. I can understand that they would expect some, since most other videos on this site have, but I honestly don't think that the purpose of this episode or even show is found in comedy. It's here to showcase people that have talent and have done great work and art, even if its only in the opinion of the DudeInSuede.

Regarding the presented AMV, I loved it. I did not recognise most of the anime included because I'm from Germany and we are still a little backwater in the anime department, but sure enough I recognised some. The thing that made this a good AMV to me is this: It made me want to see all of the animes that were included in the video. It conveyed a great and powerful affection that the creators must've held for those shows, and while some may think that is shieldish or a waste of time I salute people who can still enjoy the little things.

Regarding the future of "AMV Heaven". I say stay on course, DudeInSuede. The little joke was great and properly placed, just the right amount. This is not about comedy, not about you, but about the art and talent of others, and you have taken the honorable task of bringing it to the masses. Kudos.

So true
written by Mildula , August 03, 2008

I like Anime Heaven. But would like to see Anime Hell as well. ^_^

Your so true...I wonder how would it look like?I think tha all of the bad guys would rule that place...

I like your works, but...
written by catoblepa , August 03, 2008

...you know, this is Nostalgia Critic's home: it's good to see you have your own style, but we come here to see really BAD movies (or bad anime) and have a few laughs. That doesn't mean we can't watch a positive review now and then (James Rolfe reviewed Super Mario 3, the Critic praised many series in his Top 11, even the Spoony wrote about his favorite fantasy movie, Conan) but it should be an exception: I don't know if we're interested in a full series of nice stuff... it'd be quite boring IMHO (well, I find many AMVs boring, even the good ones. *COUGH*wasteoftime*COUGH*). You should really make an AMV Hell and destroy those horrible movies that get lots of views in Youtube, now that'd be great.

BUT WHAT WOULD BE BETTER....
written by benzaie , August 03, 2008

Would be that you keep on doing your stuff, the stuff you like to do
Keep it up THAT DUDE... BTW I saw some BERSERK Footages...but man Berserk is hardly a Shonen right ? it's SEINEN...anyway that was pretty enjoyable although pretty short...hope you'll keep one Animenia....

Awesome
written by ChadVision , August 03, 2008

I saw every anime I ever seen and then some in that AMV
Your right it would have taken years to make that.

...
written by LordVonQuack , August 03, 2008

I have to disagree with most comments here that say this video is out of place. I personally enjoy using this site as medium to promote both anime and AMVs, but I would have a legitimate complaint that this video didn't seem as well crafted as your previous. There were moments of stuttering here and there, and it lacked the every charming flare your other videos had. I've found your greatest strength in prior movies was with your words and delivering almost a whimsical property to titles when you speak of them, but I found little of that here. Regardless I can't say I didn't enjoy the video, though anyone who's watched AMVs before has bound to have seen this film at least once. Good work my friend, and keep it up.

...
written by xexyzl , August 03, 2008

All this series is gonna do is piss off AMV fanboys such as myself who baaaaaw about how their favorite editor is never featured.

...
written by Picledude , August 03, 2008

Okkay now, really dude, I haven't been as nostalgic in a good 8 months ever since I watched that first amv, maaaaan, it makes me sad that most of then ended........

I really miss Hunter x Hunter and Rurouni Kenshin
Also I liked the small detail when the 5 saints from saint seyia showed up, and ikki turns his back to us like "I'm a loner" style

...
written by xen999 , August 03, 2008

Why does so many ppl complain about the video not being comedic enough? Does it HAVE to be to be watchable/entertaining? I don't think so. My only complain is that the video was a bit short. I would've prefer seeing many amvs being showcase rather than just one. Oh and, I think it would be nice if you could pick some of your viewers suggested amvs. I remember in your last video, many people (myself included) posted a bunch of links to some pretty awesome amvs.

Good.... but.......
written by The Individual11 , August 03, 2008

I like this new show as it displays work from hard workin amv creators giving them the respect they deserve as appose 2 the Youtube community who will most likly opt for a fuzzy naruto video of 1 fight set to Linkin Park's In the End.

However I wanted 2 ask wether or not u will do any other shows as u are a talentedly funny personality who does seem 2 know his anime. Just asking because I belive u have more 2 offer than a 2 minute video of advertising....

If so can u please post and let us know. Thanx.

...
written by Monado , August 03, 2008

I like Anime Heaven. But would like to see Anime Hell as well. ^_^

I second that, Awesome video though.

Thanks for the lead
written by CoolIT , August 03, 2008

The first one I fell on was some spanish song with the same video... I was wondering what you meant my lip sink...
But I found the right AMV http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hWKT9-6UpAA

Nothing bad to say about your video and thank you for informing me about the existence of this AMV, it's quality !

I have 3 Great AMV's to show you
written by MrThumbsup , August 03, 2008

Could you give me a way to contact you? I found three that you'll want to see. One is Fullmetal Alchemist, the other 2 are Azumanga Daioh.

...
written by Sunfur , August 03, 2008

That's my man. :3 Very awesome to see a different angle of you. I liked the intro setting, it was like we were given the VIP treatment before the screening of the AMV. The pocky was also a nice touch.
AMV's can be fun to watch, but knowing a little extra something about them beforehand just makes the experience all the better. Please keep doing these! Onegai shimasu. ^^

Jihaku and Mugen
written by KoRnish , August 03, 2008

Dude, you really should show here two best AMVs ever made: Jihaku and Mugen. The are simply amazing, uses much more anime than Shonen Bushidou and shows everything that is beautif about anime. I'll kill you if you won't show them in your show, I'm not kidding ! (well... actually I am kidding, so don't call the police... please...)

PS. Sorry for bad english, etc... I'm from Poland

...
written by KoRnish , August 03, 2008

Oh, I just find out then there are more then one AMV called Mugen, so to stop the confusion I have to announce that I meant the one made by Arczi from Double A Production. And that's aboit it...

Suggestion
written by Linkvirus , August 03, 2008

I know you're probably going to get about a hundred suggestions per video but I'd still like to suggest one.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ptC9N9YJ24Y

I know the song is silly, but I think it's still an amazingly well put together video.

...
written by urnge drank , August 03, 2008

I don't think I'm a big fan of That Dude. It's probably just that I'm not very into anime.

I was wondering about that...
written by nsonic79 , August 03, 2008

nice way to work around that concern with revver and potential problems. Just a few words from you and a light commentary are enough to get the ball rolling in what you've found. And with that said, of I go! *click*

lol
written by speedrabbit , August 03, 2008

masterplan rules.....the song is damn good aswell...(spirit never die)

possible
written by fiatsolves , August 03, 2008

hey, i have a good possible amv that i thought u might just want to watch, not for this, but just for the sake of seeing it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtElPiyiVQI

...
written by Void , August 03, 2008

REALLY one of the greatest. Not only does it have TONS of anime characters in it, but the music is fairly deep and meaningful. "Never give up, never give in. Won't stop believing 'cause I'm gonna win" That practically describes the motivation of half the anime world. It's almost not a tribute, but a summary of anime entirely. A good choice for the first AMV heaven. In any case, a good start. I look forward to Episode 2.

...
written by psamathos , August 03, 2008

Awesome song, but... What a major otaku wank-fest. They might as well have used Disney characters for all it has to do with the song.

Anime fan?
written by Jedimoose , August 03, 2008

Huh. I never really thought of Doug as an anime fan. I wonder if he's showcasing Mr. Suede out of professional respect or personal interest.
AMV Heaven is certainly an interesting idea, though I hope he plans to provide more of an analysis in future episodes. Without something to contribute, he's simply linking to music videos he happens to like. Good pick, Mr. Glasses!

problem
written by scullkrusher , August 03, 2008

I cant get the damn video to work. There's no sound and it stops playing every 5 seconds or so. I let the whole video load all the way but I still cant watch it.

Seinen in my Shonen
written by MrRube , August 03, 2008

AMVs don't really do anything for me, but I was a little amused at this; Why was Guts in something that says Shonen in the title. Berserk is seinen...Seinen for Christ's sake. People get their shit wrecked with all sorts of blood sprays, decapitations, and disembowelment. Not only that but there is a very prominent rape scene. While the anime is tame compared to the manga, in either form Berserk isn't meant for kids/young teenagers.

...
written by Ryani , August 03, 2008

Question: Will there be a standard Animenia video this week?

Video is gorgeous, although I feel you should have saved it for last. Also, I feel you put more stock into lip-synching and effects than into synching the clips well with the music, both in relevance, and in rhythm. Don't get me wrong, this video does well with relevance, and is wonderfully made, but most of it is lip-synching, which some may find boring.

Your hair is starting to grow back, bit by bit!

my amvs
written by vanthebaron , August 03, 2008

now I know my amvs won't make it on here...stupid wmm

...
written by blushapple , August 04, 2008

...you know, this is Nostalgia Critic's home: it's good to see you have your own style, but we come here to see really BAD movies (or bad anime) and have a few laughs. That doesn't mean we can't watch a positive review now and then (James Rolfe reviewed Super Mario 3, the Critic praised many series in his Top 11, even the Spoony wrote about his favorite fantasy movie, Conan) but it should be an exception: I don't know if we're interested in a full series of nice stuff... it'd be quite boring IMHO (well, I find many AMVs boring, even the good ones. *COUGH*wasteoftime*COUGH*). You should really make an AMV Hell and destroy those horrible movies that get lots of views in Youtube, now that'd be great.

There's a very simple solution to this problem.

Just, don't watch his videos. ThatGuy along with the other people who personally run this site, are the ones that choose who's videos get shown. They probably wanted to throw in some variety. It brings in more users. Just having typical NC/TGWTG comedy can alienate an audience. Not everyone goes searching for that kind of humor. Adverising some tame, nice reviewing through other movie makers can bring in a wider demographic. And I personally like it. I'm not a huge fan of AMV's either, but it's not something that's commonly reviewed or given attention.

I'm sure that in the future, TGITS will review bad anime. It's out there. He might be working on something right now and just wants to surprise us. But for right now, he's like the calm, optimistic brother of the NC.

Where to start?
written by Shinjischneider , August 04, 2008

My first Post so i better think of what I'm going to write down here...

Well first of all I think i'll mention some facts about Istiv Studios.

Istiv won several Awards with this Clip and even made another one, which was also very good. (more infos here http://www.animemusicvideos.or...r_id=27839)
When i first saw the Movie i thought... "ok he put a lot of work into it... but maybe it's just flashy but without real... well..content" (to be honest, a lot of AMV-Makers try to hide their Lack of ideas and skills behind flashy special effects).
But about Istiv... he's good. He did a great Job and shows what's the difference between a good AMV and a great AMV. (I consider some of mine as not bad/good while this guy is ingenious).

Now to: AMV Heaven....

Don't get me wrong. But the Name AMV-Heaven pretty much is a rip-off of AMV-Hell. But while AMV-Hell used to show a lot of AMVs you just show us one... wait, you don't even show it. You just say. "Yes this one is good because it has good lip-sync and was done great..."
For an AMV-Heaven i'd suggest you to show more Clips and show longer scenes of them. You don't have to show the whole Clips but at leaste 20 seconds of them in a row (maybe of the best part) or 1 Minute while making comments about the effects.

What i try to say is.... show us WHY you think those AMVs are great, try to look more like someone who knows what he's talking about, instead of just another Nerd telling me "woohooo look at that, it's so great." (sorry about the harsh comment, i tend to REALLY exaggerate sometimes).


And of course like any other nerd here too i'll leave you a link to my own AMVs so you can make fun of them in return. (I especially suggest the AMV Boom... it was my first wor... you can't actually call it work... i didn't really do something with it)
http://www.youtube.com/Shinjischneider


And last but not least....

don't let yourself down because of harsh comments, but think about your name. You're on the Homepage of "THAT GUY" and call yourself "THAT GUY" too. So you'll always have to live up to the expectations of thatguywiththeglasses fans... change your name and stay unique, otherwise you might just look like a rip-off and I think that would be a waste of talent.

Greets

Shin

-----

AKA ThatGuyWhoReallyLovesToPissOfPeople

This could be a trap...
written by Shining Aquas , August 04, 2008

I remember that AMV, and I remember how awesome it is, but now that pretty just became your standard, and there is almost no way you can 1-up that one.

Still, thanks for mentioning that long lost AMV, I've been looking for 2 years to find that thing.

Great video!
written by gozzilynn , August 04, 2008

Hey what kind of pocky was that? It looked yummy. Great video! Can't wait for more!

...
written by jjthegamer , August 04, 2008

one word greatness

Hope this isn't all you make
written by thorbahn3 , August 04, 2008

As much as I love anime, AMV's aren't my thing. I hope you do some more top 11 lists or point out some more anime I might enjoy. After seeing Elfen Lied or your video I put it on my Netflix and boy was it good. Also got Lucky Stan on there waiting to be sent out.

...
written by SMcCall64 , August 05, 2008

Pardon my ignorance, but what does shonen mean? I'm just curious because I'm not as informed of japanese terms like most anime fans are and the video never really mentioned what the word means.

...
written by mushroomjay , August 05, 2008

I thought it was all fine until you ended it with you munching on pocky.

Shonen
written by LordVonQuack , August 05, 2008

Pardon my ignorance, but what does shonen mean? I'm just curious because I'm not as informed of japanese terms like most anime fans are and the video never really mentioned what the word means.

Shonen is essentially manga (the Japanese equivelent of a comic. You know, those backward books) or anime directed towards boys. Mostly they are full of action, fighting, and adventure. Dragonball Z is an infamous shonen. You know, lacking on the story but there's things beating the crap out of other things, so it works ya'know? Most of the anime seen in that video are shonen, though I can't qualify them all mostly because I knew maybe 40% of the anime shown.

So yeah, shonen are Japanese comics for males, but the wider generalization is that they're action/adventure series, but that's not absolute.

...
written by SMcCall64 , August 05, 2008

Shonen is essentially manga (the Japanese equivelent of a comic. You know, those backward books) or anime directed towards boys. Mostly they are full of action, fighting, and adventure. Dragonball Z is an infamous shonen. You know, lacking on the story but there's things beating the crap out of other things, so it works ya'know? Most of the anime seen in that video are shonen, though I can't qualify them all mostly because I knew maybe 40% of the anime shown.

So yeah, shonen are Japanese comics for males, but the wider generalization is that they're action/adventure series, but that's not absolute.

Ah. Thanks for clearing that up for me.

An AMV editors comment
written by The_Video_Editor , August 06, 2008

Istiv S. fu****' genius. I use masking in my videos too, but in Istiv videos, they/he made the masking perfectly. It's not hard to make one, but if you want to make a good one, you may work for weeks.
I recommend Kisanzi's videos too. Or mine. XD

Wiz-bag effects do not a great AMV make
written by Lord Griffin , August 07, 2008

The "best video" that you linked us to was ... good, sure. However, it really only had technical proficiency and obvious time allotment to it's credit. It also WAY overused lip-sincs. After awhile, that's just gets boring. For TRULY good videos, look to the past. If you haven't heard the name "Kevin Caldwell", then I must wonder what business you have reviewing AMVs at all. Kevin is the ONLY profile on amv.org that was aloud to be made by proxy simply because he's one of the "fathers" of AMVs. And his works stand up to the test of time to. I watch Engel several times while I'm making my own AMVs, just to get inspiration.

Also a quick question: Do you attend AMV screenings and anime conventions? These are the perfect venues to find the best of the best AS they're released. The AMV contest at Sakura-con, for example uses the Washington State Convention Center's largest room and still can't fit everybody who wants to watch it. Heck, Sakura-con has a SIDE event that's nothing but 24 hour AMV showings and this year they're being forced to take one of the large main event rooms due to heavy popularity. In other words, if you haven't attended a respectable AMV contest, you might want to check one out.

Maybe then you'll learn what makes a TRULY awesome video. ... And it's not about over using masking and lip sincs either.

Attack of the Otaku
written by Lord Griffin , August 07, 2008

After having watched your various reviews, I have a recommendation for you. I now know what kinds of openings you like, what kinds of AMVs you like and I think I have a general idea of your personal tastes. This recommendation is NOT one of my own videos. It's a video that was submitted to Sakura-con's AMV contest under the exhibition category due to do a clerical error. I've spoken with the executives of Sakura-con and have it on good word that this video WOULD have won SEVERAL awards had it been properly submitted. The video makes heavy use of dancing from Lucky Star, Haruhi Suzumia and Oran High. If you have not seen "Attack of the Otaku", then do yourself a favor and follow this link: http://www.animemusicvideos.or...p?v=154127

Sail On
written by Caliban Don Flamingo , August 09, 2008

You should review that one as it is considered by most as the definitive One Piece amv and it rocks. (I like One Piece)

...
written by doctorjackal777 , August 10, 2008

Now I don't know if I should be proud or ashamed of this but barring maybe four or five, I've seen every Anime in that video! I could list em, but I don't wanna crush you guys with a wall-o-text. But seriously that's a great AMV, and I recognised it from the closing credits of AMV Hell, I'd thought that was original but apparently not. It's nice to know where it came from.

...
written by SherlockGadget , August 14, 2008

Two words for the AMV.... absolutely... epic 0___o

duh
written by joelh790 , August 18, 2008

i think this guys a muppet

...
written by KasaiAisu , August 20, 2008

Yes! Hikaru No Go is in it!

wow
written by Morganwrath , August 26, 2008

i can see it being very hard showcasing anymore after this one, jesus

Recommendations
written by nadroj51590 , September 02, 2008

For well synced videos that tend to fit themes pretty well I'd suggest looking at Sierra Lorna and her sister Silver Moon's videos on animemusicvideos.org, and one of the best videos I've seen is http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSJuccHV25c which can also be downloaded at animemusicvideos.org.

...
written by Suntiger , September 09, 2008

Er, you guys did hear *why* he didn't show more of the AMV, right? He stated it very clearly: It's based on feedback from the previous vid he did.

About the AMV; thanks for showing the way to it. Great song and great editing. ^_^

...
written by DragonTyph , September 12, 2008

Is that Prodigy in the begining?
What song is it, it sounds AWESOME

...
written by GodOfPlague , November 16, 2008

Man that was a crazy video. I don't like Amv's much But I will give these guys props. They should do a bumper for an anime channel.

...
written by lemli , December 07, 2008

That was insanely awesome. Any chance of getting some kind of a list from you on which animes you'd suggest for people to watch? I've seen quite a few but I kinda "dropped" from the anime-scene for a good while so I got no idea of what good new ones they've managed to make.

Would also like suggestions from other Anime-watchers and wouldn't mind some oldies but goldies either.

...
written by joeshadowman , December 29, 2008

nice amv but i can't say that that's the best song in the world.