Articles Storage and Disposal Metallica - Death Magnetic
     
Metallica - Death Magnetic PDF Print E-mail
Written by Storage and Disposal   
Thursday, 11 September 2008 19:07
An optimistic look at the new Metallica CD "Death Magnetic".

Photobucket

I'm sure most of you think I have shit taste in music. Half of you probably don't even like Metallica at all and the other half probably hate anything they've done after the black album. Honestly, I'm not the biggest Metallica fan. Sure, I went through a Metallica phase a number of years back, but they were never my favorite. I shouldn't just rush in here with my opinion or it'll get ripped to shreds by anyone that wants to take the time to type something. I'll need to start from the beginning and work my way up. Even after I do this, people will probably rip it to shreds, but at least this way I might convince a few people to think otherwise. Anyway, from the beginning...

Metallica was the shit in the '80s. Through relentless touring, they made a big name for themselves with little or no radio play and no "singles". This was all while the hair metal scene flourished, so it must have been nice to hear something different. And strangely enough, they kept getting better and better with each album. It is my opinion that they peaked with ...And Justice For All, though several die hard fans would say they sold out by making music videos and appealing to a broader audience. Maybe they did, but that doesn't change the fact that the album sounds amazing by Metallica album standards. It was the start of the second Metallica movement that only lasted 2 albums, the black album being the second of the two. Songs were starting to lose that pure thrash feeling that Kill 'Em All, Ride the Lighting, and Master of Puppets had. Still, ...And Justice For All had some of the heaviest parts they wrote at the time and the songs were getting longer, which seems to go against what I would see as an attempt to become more accessible. It was acceptable, in my opinion. The black album was more melodic and seemed to be their biggest success. It was still thrash, but it had melodies that appealed to just about everyone. The songs were shorter and less aggressive but it's still a great album. Despite this, it seemed to mark the beginning of the slope that was Metallica in the '90s.

After taking a few years off, Metallica came back with a different look and a different sound. Solos were far more scarce and the thrashiness was all but gone. Still, I had a pretty open mind about it and managed to enjoy a few songs from the album, namely "Bleeding Me". Still, this wasn't old school Metallica. It's songs took on a more southern influence. Either this was just an experimental phase and they would come back to their senses with the next album or they truly lost it. Unfortunately, they seemed to dig themselves deeper with Reload. By the time Garage Inc came around, it seemed to continue this new sound, but now they weren't even writing their own music. One or two good covers are found on it, but nothing that seemed to come close to beating their old sound. In most cases, I would rather listen to the original anyway. S and M seemed like a desperate attempt to reconnect with their old fans, but I never bothered buying it. I would rather just pick up my old Metallica CD's and listen to some metal. An orchestra isn't necessary for that.

After taking a number of years off again, Metallica started talking about returning to their roots with a heavier sound. Without listening to much of the album, I bought it with high expectations. This proved to be a big mistake on my part. There were some heavy parts on St. Anger, but gone now were the albums full of satisfying guitar solos. It was a disappointment that was fairly damaging. If this was going back to their roots, then Metallica was dead as far as I was concerned. Musically, it went for a raw feeling and succeeded in a way, but still missed the mark as far as I'm concerned. I always thought the lyrics were a strong suit when it came to Metallica. They had themes that were pretty standard for a metal band, the kind that would fuel the "I want to break or charge at something" mentality, but at the same time they seemed a little more thought provoking. That didn't seem like the case to me with St. Anger. What am I supposed to do with "I'm madly in anger with you"? At this point, I was beyond giving up on Metallica. They were getting old and seemed to be grasping at straws.

Then I heard news of a new Metallica album earlier this year. I was at my friends house when we were talking about it and he said, "Hey Storage! Guess what song is on the new Metallica album!" I had no idea what he was referring to. Did they stoop so low as to just re-record old songs and try to pass them off as new except this time without an orchestra? No. It turns out that they have a song called "Unforgiven III". That's right. Unforgiven 3. They tried to bank off of their most successful album before with "Unforgiven II", and now they're doing it again. I didn't think there was any hope for this album at all. In fact, I fully expected Metallica's worst, but I was still curious as to what this would sound like.

I went ahead and watched their video and, well, it wasn't really that bad. It was nothing like their '80s sound, but it was a definite improvement over St. Anger. The first half seemed relatively typical, but the second half was pure metal. I decided to listen to some others and each track seemed to sound better than the one before. "Unforgiven III" sounded almost like an outtake of Load, but with a touch of the black album. It wasn't amazing by any means, but it wasn't as bad as I had thought it would be. It didn't sound much like "Unforgiven" or "Unforgiven II", which was reassuring. I can only take so much of one sound. The only thing that links it together with the others is the forgiveness theme. Other songs sounded reminiscent of ... And Justice For All and the black album, namely "All Nightmare Long". Not as good as those albums, but still a step in the right direction. I listened to half of the songs from this CD and they're not half bad. If this is a good representation of what the entire CD sounds like, then it'll be their best CD in nearly 20 years. The Solos are back, they're tighter, and this just might be the longest original Metallica album ever recorded.

I guess if you ever were a fan of Metallica, I would suggest checking this album out, but listen to some tracks before you buy it. There's still a chance that I'm way off on this one. They did trick me into buying St. Anger, afterall. You can find some new songs if you search for them on youtube. I don't think it'll be as good as anything they did in the '80s, but I think it'll at least kick '90s Metallica's ass.
This article was done by Storage and Disposal

Donating gives you access to the Premium Member Download Area, where you can download full Episodes in MPG and IPOD Video formats. You also get access to Extras, Bloopers and Commentaries!
Donate today and help keep this site running, cause it's damn expensive!

You can view copyright info here >
Comments (26)add
5647
Agreement
written by Segwo , September 11, 2008
I must say.... I totally agree... with almost everything you said.... well yea everything you said. Just one complaint from me, and its that they didn't use the same three second soundclip from the first two Unforgiven.. That ruined the song for me right there.... All Nightmare Long is definitely my favorite song on the album tho
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
4793
Eh
written by ShockedAndAmused , September 11, 2008
The album is streaming at Metallica.com. Personally, I only listened to two songs. The second one ("The End of the Line") steals a riff from a Pearl Jam song, but it was still okay. If it's still up tomorrow I'll listen to the whole thing.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -3
2225
...
written by TylerDirty529 , September 11, 2008
I've only heard two songs so far, "The Day That Never Comes" and "Cyanide."

I plan on doing a track-by-track review of it (in the same style as a St. Anger review I posted as a blog) tomorrow.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
2404
Sort of agree but...
written by ResidentialEvil , September 11, 2008
I've listened to the whole album and personally I think it's as good as ...And Justice For All and definitely deserves to be in the same breath as the "holy trinity" of Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets and AJFA.

Perhaps I'm a bit overreacting to it because it's nothing like Load, ReLoad, or thankfully St. Anger, but I love every track so far. The Day That Never Comes is just a killer track, as is All Nightmare Long. And Suicide and Redemption is a killer instrumental.

The only weak song to me is Unforgiven 3, but even that song I like. I just wish they had called it something else instead of labeling it U3.

Bravo Metallica, you pulled off what I didn't think you could after St. Anger.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
323
...
written by storage and disposal , September 11, 2008
Yeah, it's streamed now and I'm pretty impressed. I wrote this review a week ago when they weren't on their site yet, but the admin never got it. I had to resend my review today. Damn internet!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
R.I.P. Metallica 1981 - 1989, Lowly rated comment [Show]
323
...
written by storage and disposal , September 12, 2008
It hurts me to see some people write stuff like "This is the best thing they released ever" cuz it definitely isn't
Well, good news for you. No one wrote anything like that here.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +3
..., Lowly rated comment [Show]
5502
Great guitars, crappy drums
written by rocknrollguy86 , September 12, 2008
Death Magnetic is o.k. I've only heard 1 or 2 songs and they sound decent. The guitars have definitely improved from St. Anger but my main complaint is Lars. Lars has NO CREATIVITY AT ALL! During the second half of The Day that Never Comes, the guitars kick it up a notch and start thrashing and what does Lars do? He plays the same beat throughout the rest of the song, even when the guitars do different riffs. It's so aggravating listening to James and Kirk play their hearts out and then Lars is doing the same thing over and over and over...snare bass snare bass snare bass snare bass over and over. No creativity whatsoever. Maybe it's because I've been listening to Rush non-stop for the last two months and Dream Theater before that. But, its still a whole lot better than St. Anger, where the drums were even worse. People just need to calm down. Nothing will ever be as good as Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets, or And Justice For All. I'll stick with Megadeth any day.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2
92
...
written by Lordifani , September 13, 2008
I bought the album yesterday and it was awesome! Not their best but one of their best. I especially loved the first half of the album, pure fuckin' Metallica-gold! smilies/cool.gif
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
5103
Meh
written by EvilSandwich , September 13, 2008
I don't care if that album is the greatest thing they ever produced. Metallica has been dead to me ever since Lars Ulrich bitched and moaned about Napster until they were shut down, setting the freedom of information movement back for years.

Charging million of dollars to put on a concert? Oh yeah, piracy is really making them suffer... smilies/angry.gif
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -3
5018
POne word to describe the new Metallica Album "Deathmagnetic"
written by katsumi , September 15, 2008
Rebarbative.

Why do you ask? Well I've been waiting for Metallica to put out an album that was worth listening to for years and then they came out with this bullshit. I am so very disappointed in them as I know they could've done a kick ass job giving the time they had to make this album.

Even the album's name "Deathmagnetic" sounds like something Dethklok would make up for a song. Oh wait, isn't one of Dethklok's songs called Dethharmonic? Wow Metallica, that's some originality there! You should be ashamed of yourselves, coping off a cartoon show.

I really like Metallica's old music, up to the Black Album and I haven't seen them in concert because I think it's crazy to pay $75 to listen to their new music which isn't that great at all. I do consider myself a fan though but I am not going to be part of the herd and buy the new album. That's what boyfriends and Lime wire is for.


OF course my B/F loves it but if Metallica came out with anm album that just has them farting out the tracks he would think it should win a Grammy. Fucktards!

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -4
5839
Interesting
written by Hermitninja , September 16, 2008
I myself am a big fan of old school Metallica. I haven't checked out "Deathmagnetic" yet, but considering the review I'd say its worth the ten bucks. However, I am very disappointed that you hadn't checked out S&M before. Although it may be all the same songs, the elements that the California philharmonic brings to the table add a whole new dimension to all our old favorites. For starters, the orchestra doesn't actually play the songs, but instead plays whole new melodies that act to reinforces the originals while giving them a new twist. The end result (in my opinion) is definitely worth the time of checking out. You can find almost all of the songs on youtube with fairly good quality, so you can go check them out if you don't want to buy the album.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
447
Same ol' Same ol'
written by garethxxgod , September 16, 2008
Metallica is at a point where they should consider retirement or atleast a lengthy prolonged break where the guys can go and perhaps start their own spin off bands of sort.

To be honest though, Death Magnetic was okay I suppose. Not terrible and atleast better (but not much) than the Demo that I had passed onto me by a couple of sites earlier this year. They've been desperately trying to regain ground since the Load/Reload debacle and now they've come pretty close to atleast capturing the spirit of the black album....however in my opinion it's definitely too little too late.

I liken this idea of Ebert's review or comments on the 1998 remake of Psycho (which ironically I don't mind) with which he said "why not just watch the original"? I guess for flavour or if you have to listen to something "NEW" Metallica, but if I ever want to listen to when they were still good I think I'll listen from Kill Them All till the Black Album and be happy with that.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
5122
Loudness wars claim another victim
written by Anthony , September 16, 2008
This album deserve a good mix!!!! I love the songs but the mix makes this album unlistenable at even mild volumes. There is no stereo separation and the dynamic range is non-existent. This album needs to be fixed. Its sad that we have to resort to ripping the tracks from guitar hero to get a decent sounding tracks. If ST anger was mixed this way it would have been ok because the album was crap, but this is a good album that has a terrible production holding it down.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
314
It's good.
written by Hand_Of_Doom , September 16, 2008
Metallica isn't going to make another "Master of Puppets" or "Ride the Lightning." It's just not gonna happen. However, Death Magnetic is a very good album, especially when you compare it to what they've been doing. Load and Reload are at least tolerable, and St. Anger was just a piece of shit. However, Death Magnetic is a breath of fresh air. Great album. I wouldn't mind seeing another album like this from these guys, if they decide to make another. ^_^

Best tracks: "All Nightmare Long", "Cyanide", "The Day That Never Comes", "Suicide & Redemption" and "The Judas Kiss."
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
1486
Very decent album.
written by HeLLRaZoR , September 16, 2008
I personally give this album a 6.5/10, Obviously it was not their best album, but it is an album worth checking out, it steps all over the shitstorm called St.Anger.
I actually bought the Album from Guitar Hero 3, and I'd say at least half the songs are really solid.
When coming back from a shitty album like St.Anger you have no choice but to acknoledge Death Magnetic, even the sound of a farting bubbly ass is a masterpiece compared to St.Anger.



report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
3205
...
written by brynjarbjorn , September 17, 2008
I don't think people should have been expecting anything that would have surpassed their greatest albums. It is very, very tough to outmatch your greatest work and I think people tend to forget just how much impact Cliff Burton's demise had on Metallica, and just how much influence he had on them while he was still alive.
'...and Justice for All' reportedly featured his last writing credit. It is the first album which they released after Burton's death, after which they move on to 'Black Album' and generally the albums that people mean when talking about Metallica's decline. Who knows what might have happened if their coach accident in Sweden had never taken place and Burton hadn't died so prematurely.

Death Magnetic is not bad, it is fairly good. But it certainly is not (and should not) be on-par to 'Kill 'Em All', 'Ride the Lightning, 'Master of Puppets' or '...and Justice for All'.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +3
5880
...
written by pwnstar , September 17, 2008
this there best work since "....and justice for all" and sounds a lot like it, there best song is unforgiven III.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
5794
...
written by Mean Matt , September 17, 2008
I listened to Metallica since i was in grade 10, I was 16 and looking to approve my fondness of metal, cause all i was listening to the music of Korn and Slipknot......my favourite band in Highschool was Nirvana, who was not metal, and the lead singer blew his brains out/or murdered 7 years earlier at the time. My friend was really into Metallica at the time, and i he brought his CDs to class, i was happy. I remember seeing the "Until It Sleeps" video when i was 12, and thought they were a shock rock band, like a Manson type thing.
I guess the difference between me, in my opinion, is when im first into a band, im in it for life! Most people who loved a band, now hated them for doing something god awful, this annoyed me! I am still very much a fan.

Long live METAL!!!

AND

Long live METALLICA!!!!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
5018
...
written by katsumi , September 18, 2008
I mean look at them! They don't even look like rockstars! They washed out and the only reason why their album ranked #1 is all the blind sheep who flocked to buy the album. SAD, SAD, SAD!!!!

I listen to them when I was 14 years old and that was 17 years ago. I know what good Metallica is and quite frankly, this is not good Metallica.

BAAA BAAA!! Go flock to them you sheep! I bet you'll vote for Obama Christ too! BAAAAAAAAA!!!! Straight to the slaughter!! BAAA!!!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
4439
Metallica will always be awesome!
written by angry_nostalgia_video_game_critic_nerd , September 18, 2008
I don't mean to sound like a fan boy, but Metallica is one of the best bands to have ever come out of any music scene. Kill Em' All was brutal beyond belief, Ride The Lightning is my favorite album they ever released, and Master Of Puppets is a great album dealing with social problems. Then Cliff Burton died, and that truly sucked balls. But with ...And Justice For All, they recovered, unfortunately with Jason Newsted, who was so bland and added nothing cool to the mixture, it's like he was dead with creativity, and I swear, if you watch the music video for One, you can see Cliff Burton trying to strangle Newsted for being a shitty bassist.
Then after that, came the Black Album, which, in all regard, is not that great; while it was the second album by them I ever listened to, after listening to everything else, it just doesn't stand up as well as the previous four albums. Load was soon to come after this, and to tell the truth, I actually enjoyed this album; it had some catchy songs (particularly Hey Big Spend... I mean 2X4), and what's more, I kind of liked the new sound, just a little bit, but I tend to think that the reason why it was changed was because James just couldn't pull off his old vocals. Now, ReLoad on the other hand, was rather dull and boring, but I'm still able to listen to it every once in a while, if I'm having a very good day, like it's pay day or if I finally lost my virginity (no wait, that's reserved for St. Anger).
Garage Inc. was intended to be a cover album, and it was rather good at doing that, it definitely had covers, but two they could have left off were Luverman and Die, Die My Darling, these songs just had pretentious written up and down them like a concrete wall at the Pavilion (a local music joint where only the most metal of bands play, there's even a special space reserved for Metallica); but all together, it's not a bad album as I do enjoy their cover of Astronomy and even Tuesday's Gone.
Then there was a sort of drought, where we only had S&M released, and while it wasn't bad, you really can only the DVD form of it, you're imagination isn't good enough to think of the San Fran Orcastra playing Metallica with them on stage at the same time.
But, then we had a really downer, St. Anger!
Now, I will admit that the first three songs are pretty good, and I can listen to them no problem, but then the next eight songs kick in unless you hit the stop button, to which, you better hope you're CD Player intervine's and plays some Black Sabbath or self destructs. Also, by this time, Jason Newsted had gone on to sell out to a another band called Supernova, which just plains suck, so they replaced him with Robert Trujilo, who is almost as good as Burton, but just barely.
Now, we finally come to the latest album, Death Magnetic, which is such a weird title, I mean, it's not really what you'd expect, I mean, really if they were going to title it anything, you think they could've called it Magnetic Death, but hey, I'm not James Hetfield. Now, my opinion of this album is they take Load, ReLoad, S&M and St. Anger, throw them out the window and say they never existed, they were on haiutus for nearly 20 years and that Garage Inc. is nothing more than a bootleg album. There is a definite feel like they've returned to their old style, and I must admit that my favorite song on this album is the instrumental piece Suicide and Redemption. But I'm so thankful that there are guitar solos again, it's just so excellent to finally hear a solo that has goes a tempo faster than 120 bpm. And also, the song The Unforgiven III is such a nice change of pace, it even has a hint of The Ectasy of Gold, the song that starts off every show they've played since the eighties, and it really is nice.
If you are one of the few who still has hope in Metallica, definitely give this album a listen.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
4338
...
written by moscoweddie , September 18, 2008
What wrong with obama katsumi?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
323
...
written by storage and disposal , September 19, 2008
They don't even look like rockstars!

If fashion is key to making good music, then I'm afraid you're listening to the wrong music. You don't necessarily have to have a certain look to play something decent.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
4708
...
written by StinkyJoe , September 21, 2008
If fashion is key to making good music, then I'm afraid you're listening to the wrong music. You don't necessarily have to have a certain look to play something decent.


Yes, actually it does. Example

Good band

Shitty band

Good band

Shitty band
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -3
4388
i just need to add one thing
written by tigerthecat5 , September 22, 2008
just to help make it clear why there stuff wasent as heavy as pupets and back now i havent read the comments so i dont know if someone pointed this out but why there stuff isnt heavy is cause cliff burton wrote most of there stuff and they were tring to copy cliffs work but had cliff burton still been alive today metallica wouldent be the same and i think death magnetic is boack to what made metallica great
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 

Login

RSS Feed

 Subscribe to the Update Feed

New Videos

Sage: Best/Worst PS3 Games

Watch Video

Ask: Aussie & Suede

Watch Video

Ask ThatGuy: User Edition

Watch Video

Spoony: Phantasmagoria

Watch Video

Linkara: Spiderman #56

Watch Video

Still Gaming: Fallout 3

Watch Video

NC: Jingle all the Way

Watch Video

Linkara: Batman #147

Watch Video

Linkara: Sinnamon #11

Watch Video

Spoony: Year in Review

Watch Video

Happy Holidays 2008

Watch Video

5 Sec: Die Hard

Watch Video

NChick: Top 10 Christmas Songs

Watch Video


RocketTheme Joomla Templates